• SPECIAL ARTICLE ON HEALTH SCIENCES RESEARCH IN PUERTO RICO •
The Educational Legacy of the UPR School of Tropical Medicine: Curricula, Faculty, Students
Silvia E. Rabionet, EdD
This essay discusses the educational evolution of the University of Puerto Rico- School of Tropical Medicine
Key words: Public health training, Medical education in Puerto Rico, History of education, History of medical education
The main purpose of the University of Puerto Rico School of Tropical Medicine
The
During the two decades that followed, there were significant evolutions and trends in the School which can be attributed to a group of scholars, academic administrators and students that engaged in investigating, teaching, learning and delivering sanitary and clinical care. These changes stemmed from the transformation of the dynamics in the relationship between Columbia University and the University of Puerto Rico; the public health and clinical workforce needs of the Island; and the advancement and discoveries in the basic, clinical and social sciences. This second article of a series of five historical articles on the scientific and educational contributions of the
Social Sciences Department, Graduate School of Public Health, University of Puerto Rico & Sociobehavioral and Administrative Pharmacy Department, College of Pharmacy, Nova Southeastern University
The author has no conflict of interest to disclose.
Address correspondence to: Silvia E. Rabionet, EdD, College of Pharmacy 3200
South University Drive Fort Lauderdale, FL
PRHSJ Vol. 35 No. 3 • September, 2016 |
125 |
School of Tropical Medicine Educational Legacy |
Rabionet |
Elements of the School’s Intellectual and Educational Foundation
A. The
The
Manson played a major role in the creation of the foundation for the teaching of tropical medicine by identifying its body of knowledge. Following his memorable lectures on the teaching of tropical medicine, published in the Lancet in 1897 and in the Journal of Tropical Medicine in 1899, he fueled a
During the first decade of 20th century, schools of tropical medicine flourished rapidly. These schools, modelled after the two British institutions, facilitated the consolidation of tropical medicine as an academic discipline. They provided a distinct curriculum and field experiences to physicians and other medical personnel who were expected to work in colonies or were attending persons who returned to the Unite Kingdom and had become ill in warm climate countries. Besides teaching about the diseases, the schools disseminated ways to conduct laboratory and clinical investigations using materials gathered or observed in the colonies. In the years that followed, schools and institutes devoted to the study of tropical diseases and its consequences opened in major European countries and in their colonies; notably, the Institute für
Tropical medicine as a medical and scientific specialty was conceived unequivocally in Europe and the United States for the very specific needs of colonialism and imperial expansion. The development of the discipline and its teaching was intimately, but not exclusively, related to diseases defined geographically. It also had been defined by the geopolitical occurrences of the end of the 19th century and the beginning of the 20th century. Europeans and developed nations usually preferred underdeveloped regions in warm climates to spread Christianity, to colonize and then profit from local resources, to expand agricultural industries, pay for wars, or to conduct all four simultaneously (10). Several events and scientific advancements contributed to the pertinence and growth of the medical discipline, among them the discoveries at the time that left behind the miasma theories of disease, the need to maintain a healthy military workforce, mainly in warm climates, and the increasing responsibility and
The institutions in the metropolis and colonies also attracted scientists that had been working in the various localities. On the one hand, we have many documented instances in which there was an evident clash of power and science between the Western scientific traditions and motives, and the local struggles with health and disease (14). In clear contrast, positive collaborations, scientific synergy, discoveries and even profound friendships resulted from the interactions (15). In 1926, the
B. A singular position within the development of the University of Puerto Rico
While the School of Tropical Medicine was being conceived as a
126PRHSJ Vol. 35 No. 3 • September, 2016
School of Tropical Medicine Educational Legacy |
Rabionet |
The University was founded in 1903, only five years after the United States assumed control of Puerto Rico. The 1903 Organic Law explicitly supported a university with strong liberal arts and professional components. Initially, the Puerto Rico legislature only provided funds for the Normal School for teacher training (1903) and an Agriculture Department (1904).
During the same decade the University also established the College of Liberal Arts (1910), the School of Law (1913), and the School of Pharmacy (1913). Despite this expansion, the University remained underdeveloped (19).
WhenPresidentWarrenG.Harding appointed Horace M. Towner as governor in 1923, Puerto Rico and the University of Puerto Rico entered a new era. Towner favored statehood and encouraged initiatives to provide the Island’s government with more
autonomy (20). Also, he created the conditions in Puerto Rico to launch a program to facilitate initiatives between the United States and the Caribbean, Central and South American countries.
Towner identified the University of Puerto Rico as a vehicle for the
In 1924, Thomas E. Benner was appointed as the first Chancellor of the University. He was charged with the implementation of the
administrative challenges, and that the University had to share its power, the School provided a platform and framework to achieve many of the elements that he had envisioned, such as: collaboration with a University with high standards, the influx of visiting scholars, the projection to provide health services to the Puerto Rican population, insertion in the research enterprise, and the potential to attract foreign students. The School, following the tradition of other schools of Tropical Medicine, benefited from scholarly networks, including those inherent to the discipline of tropical medicine and related fields, the medical practice, the higher education Ivy League community, and the worldwide medical philanthropy that was at its pinnacle. The School, as part of the University of Puerto Rico, was readily showcased in the scientific and lay press as an institution committed to high scientific international standards and responsive to the needs of Puerto Ricans (25).
Evidence of Evolution, Growth and Legacy
The School evolved in the context of a dynamic University environment, and within political turmoil and lack of resources that stemmed from the Second World War and the Great Depression. It prevailed amid the tensions created by the neocolonial environment in which it was established; it also had to withstand the challenges that emanated from two institutions with different missions, purposes, traditions, administrative structures and educational priorities. The School operated and became a significant academic enterprise for twenty three years. It ceased its activities in 1949. Its resources, facilities and activities were redefined when the University of Puerto Rico
PRHSJ Vol. 35 No. 3 • September, 2016 |
127 |
School of Tropical Medicine Educational Legacy |
Rabionet |
School of Medicine was created. Its growth and legacy can be assessed through its curricular offering, student body and faculty pursuits.
A. Curricula and student body
The
The courses were mainly designed for graduate students or graduates in medicine or public health. All the courses had a predetermined number of points based on the hours of dedication. They usually lasted one semester. In some cases the courses were offered in a concentrated time frame to accommodate the needs of the students or to incorporate visiting professors of renowned expertise who came to the School. Recognizing the fact that individual interests widely varied, it was the “policy of the School to allow as much freedom as possible in the choice of studies? (27). It should be highlighted that this flexible curricular platform remained unchanged and continued until
Field work was an integral part of the educational experience required of students and investigators. The sites for field work changed over the years as a reflection of where the Puerto Rico Department of Health had active locations or needs. These
sites were supplemented with locations not directly under the Department of Health, but that could offer unique experiences and relevant samples and data to conduct studies of tropical disease and afflictions. The Announcement of the Second Session
The School awarded different types of credentialing, which were consonant with the flexibility and different training modalities it provided. A Certificate in Tropical Medicine was awarded to physicians upon completion of at least one year’s work in residence and finalizing an approved course of study with a minimum of thirty points, ten of which were towards the preparation of a thesis. A special examination was required to obtain the certificate, in addition to the usual course tests. The Certificate was awarded by the University of Puerto Rico. Students that participated in individual courses or short trainings received certificates of completion. Those students who pursued studies in other institutions could receive credit for their work in their institution of origin. Because of the agreement with Columbia University, credits for courses taken in the School were accepted by that university, and were credited for pursuing a Master of Arts and Doctor of Philosophy degrees. These platforms for credentialing evidenced the scholarly nature and the recognition of the School had within the established medical training institutions, especially in the United States (31).
For the first decade and a half since the
128PRHSJ Vol. 35 No. 3 • September, 2016
School of Tropical Medicine Educational Legacy |
Rabionet |
Excerpt of Courses of Studies (Bacteriology).
Puerto Rico Department of Health or had a particular interest in conducting epidemiological studies related to specific health issues such as tuberculosis, leprosy, malaria, and nutrition. They worked closely with faculty and visiting scholars, and their work was published frequently in the journal issued by the School (32). Many of the students later became leaders in their fields, joined the faculty of the
There was at least one international student enrolled in each entering class, starting with the class of 1926. During its first decade the School had enrolled students from Spain, Brussels, China, India, the Philippines, Dominican Republic, Haiti, Brazil and the British Virgin Islands. During the summer session it
also attracted a group of students under the tutelage of visiting professors from universities in major cities of the United States, including Washington, D.C., New York, Rochester, Baltimore, Boston, and Cincinnati (34). However, the international linkages that the School aimed to have through its student body was not fulfilled. When Carlos Chardón, Chancellor on the University of Puerto Rico, was approached to increase funding for the School, he wrote a letter dated April 24, 1934 to Willard C. Rappleye, dean of the Columbia College of Medicine, in which he rejected the possibility of further monetary contributions and pointed out his perception that the School had a limited international impact, especially in Latin America.
The situation in the future, insofar as Puerto Rico is concerned, needs to be seriously considered, not because of our interest in the School shall be less, but because we have now reached a point in which further monetary contributions from our University funds are impossible. However, we realize that the School of Tropical Medicine needs to grow, in order to meet the increasing demands for service to the countries in Latin America. Here is a great and practically unexplored field which stands as a challenge to our mutual efforts. Sooner or later, we shall have to meet this service, if the School is to attain the high international objectives for which it was founded (35).
As the 1940s approached, the
The new training venture brought tensions associated with the transformation of higher education institutions, including the professionalization of a mainly scholarly institution, the diversification of missions and purposes, the expansion without sufficient resources, and the acceptance of different levels of students. These transformational forces had been identified in higher learning institutions, especially after the Great Depression (36). There was an overall general trend in universities worldwide to expand its scope and be more accountable to the environment in which they were located. In the
PRHSJ Vol. 35 No. 3 • September, 2016 |
129 |
School of Tropical Medicine Educational Legacy |
Rabionet |
and Columbia University. According to Ramírez de Arellano, each of these institutions “had a different concept of aims, scope and character of the training.? There were different points of view regarding the types of programs, at what level and who should be trained. Also, as discussed by Ramírez de Arellano, issues of personality, power struggles and financial support in times of war resulted in an uncertain start of the public health training programs (37).
Starting in February of 1941, a total of 33 students were enrolled in courses for sanitarians leading to a Certificate in Public Health Practice, courses for nurses leading to the Certificate of Public Health Nursing and courses for laboratory assistants leading to a Certificate in Medical Technology. Although the number of offerings and students fell short of expectations, as the years progressed, the School experienced a transformation in its training mission that was well established by 1949 (38). This full expression of this new training mission became clear when the STM was absorbed and transformed into the University of Puerto
After the
B. Faculty: Recruitment, sponsorship and development Financing the faculty and its work was a struggle for the School since its establishment. The academic administrators of both institutions had to pursue different strategies and modalities to attract and sustain a cadre of
inadequacy of financial guarantees became evident. For the initial session in 1926, Columbia University agreed to assume the salaries of four resident professors who joined the School from the United States and to cover traveling expenses of three visiting professors. Appropriations from the University of Puerto Rico were mainly devoted to facilities and administrative costs. These were independent from tuition revenues (40).
In 1926, The faculty was organized in a) four basic sciences departments: Bacteriology, Mycology and Immunology; Pathology; Chemistry; and Medical Zoology, b) a clinical department called Tropical Medicine and Surgery, and c) a department of Public Health and Communicable Diseases. No major changes were made to this structure until the 1940s when the School started to offer public health degrees. Academic appointments were conferred by Columbia University and faculty was initially recruited through the Columbia’s scholarly connections (41). The faculty was classified in different ways, which illustrates the diverse roles and the articulation with the hospital.
Throughout the years, the faculty affiliated to the School grew substantially, and their scholarly fields diversified. However, there were challenging moments for sustaining the number of faculty to conduct all the activities for which the School had committed. For example, at the beginning of the 1940s, with the advent of the Second World War, maintaining the cadre of faculty became a challenge. Many of the members of the clinical faculty were drafted to service by the United States Army and Navy. As a strategy to staff the hospital, young female graduates of the Medical School were hired at the University Hospital (42). Also of preoccupation to the administration was the steadiness of the faculty since very few permanent positions were available (43).
The School relied heavily on visiting professors. The School seemed to prosper and to welcome the potential collaboration and networks that could result from the visits, as reported by the different directors throughout the years. Besides Columbia University, the University of Chicago, New York University, Harvard University and the Rockefeller Foundation established sustained collaborations throughout the existence of the School by sending faculty for prolonged periods. Many remained for a few months to conduct investigations and offer lectures to students, local physicians and practicing health professionals. They also were responsible for some lectures that were open to the public and, on many occasions, they recommended and brought students to participate in summer sessions and in special courses. To these we can add hundreds of other scholars from a wide range of institutions that visited the School with different purposes and for shorter periods of time. Mainly they came to the School to see how it was set up and to meet with specific scholars (44).
Members of the faculty were expected to have a significant scientific production. Throughout the years the scientific work of the faculty increasingly received external funding, sponsorship and resources in staffing or assistantship. The scope of the clinical and service work of the clinical faculty also
130PRHSJ Vol. 35 No. 3 • September, 2016
School of Tropical Medicine Educational Legacy |
Rabionet |
escalated to a significant health enterprise after the first decade of the School’s operation. Opportunities for development and specialization were available to the faculty. Many spent time pursuing additional training in collaboration with the visiting scholars that came to the School (45). As the operation of the
Conclusions
The
The School’s activities also provided training and continuing education opportunities for practitioners. Regular weekly lectures were offered during the academic year and were open to practicing physicians for more than two decades. The impact of such activity could be the subject of further exploration. The interaction created by the different collaborating institutions and associations with roots on the island and elsewhere that used the School as a venue to meet, consolidate support and establish further collaborations was a fascinating finding. A more systematic analysis of the involvement and the collaboration of these institutions could be an interesting subject to study from a historical and sociological perspective. These collaborations had an impact on how different health professions were established and credentialed in the Island.
During the two decades of its existence, activities and events occurred within the School that were foundational for the professionalization of the health sciences in Puerto Rico, including medical education. Other than its singular place in the history of the teaching of tropical medicine, the
Resumen
Este ensayo presenta la evolución de la Escuela de Medicina Tropical de la Universidad de Puerto Rico
References
1.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Announcement
2.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Announcement
3.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Announcement
4.
5.Haynes DM. Imperial Medicine: Patrick Manson and the Conquest of Tropical Disease; Philadelphia, PA; University of Pennsylvania Press, 2001. Cook GC. From the Greenwich Hulks to Old St Pancras: A History of Tropical Disease in London; London; The Atholone Press, 1992:
6.Arnold D. Introduction: Tropical medicine before Manson. In: Arnold D (ed.). Warm Climates and Western Medicine.
PRHSJ Vol. 35 No. 3 • September, 2016 |
131 |
School of Tropical Medicine Educational Legacy
Editions Rodopi, 1996:
Old St Pancras: A History of Tropical Disease in London; London; The
Atholone Press, 1992:
7.
8.Manson P. The necessity for special education in tropical medicine. Lan- cet 1897; ii:
9.For example, Maegraith BG. History of the Liverpool School of Tropi- cal Medicine. Medical History
10.Cook GC. From the Greenwich Hulks to Old St Pancras: A History of Tropical Disease in London; London; The Atholone Press, 1992:
11.Gibson A. Miasma revisited: The intellectual history of tropical medicine. Aust Fam Phys
12.Vedder EB. Presidential Address American Society of Tropical Medicine Nov 1935 Tropical Medicine. Am J Public Health
13.Manson P. Tropical Diseases: A Manual of the Diseases of Warm Climates. New York; W. Wood and Company, 1903: xxiv. Wilson CM. Ambassadors in White: The Story of American Tropical Medicine; New York, NY; Henry Holt and Company, 1942.
14.Mayo Santana R, Rabionet SE. “They could not accept a master? Bai- ley K. Ashford. Conflictos en la fundación de la Escuela de Medicina Tropical. Conference held under the auspices of
15.Mayo Santana R, Ramírez de Arellano AB,
16.Ramírez de Arellano AB. The Politics of Medical Education in Puerto Rico; School of Public Health, Columbia University; Doctoral Diss: 1985:23p.
17.St Petersburg’s Times. Porto Rico Medic School: Columbia University back project to study tropical disease first hand; March 13, 1926, 39p.
18.Rabionet SE. The Influence of the Puerto Rico Commission on the Uni- versity of Puerto Rico Reform Movement; Graduate School of Educa- tion; Harvard University; Doctoral Diss: 2002: 16p. Benner, T. Five Years of Foundation Building: The University of Puerto Rico
19.Rabionet SE. The Influence of the Puerto Rico Commission on the Uni- versity of Puerto Rico Reform Movement; Graduate School of Educa- tion; Harvard University; Doctoral Diss: 2002: 16p.
20.Trías Monge J. Puerto Rico: The Trials of the Oldest Colony in the World;
New Haven, Yale University Press, 1997:
21.Benítez J. Junto a la Torre: Jornada de un Programa Universitario; Río Pie-
dras: Editorial Universitaria, 1962: 433p.
22.Puerto Rico Legislature, Public Law 67, (28 July 1923) and Public Law 50, (21 July 1925) [Puerto Rico Legislative Archival Library]. Rabionet SE. The Influence of the Puerto Rico Commission on the University of Puerto Rico Reform Movement; Graduate School of Education; Harvard University; Doctoral Diss: 2002: 18 p. Navarro Rivera P. Universidad de Puerto Rico: De control político a crisis permanente 1903- 1952; Río Pie- dras, Ediciones Huracán, 2000: 25p.
132PRHSJ Vol. 35 No. 3 • September, 2016
Rabionet
23.Benner T. Five Years of Foundation Building: The University of Puerto Rico
24.Benner T. Five Years of Foundation Building: The University of Puerto Rico
25.For example: Lambert RA. Escuela de Medicina Tropical de la Universidad de Puerto Rico: Bajo los auspicios de Columbia. Revista Oficina Sanitaria Panamericana 1928;
26.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Announcement
27.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the aus- pices of Columbia University, Announcement
28.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the aus- pices of Columbia University, Announcement
29.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the aus- pices of Columbia University, Announcement
30.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the aus- pices of Columbia University, Announcement
31.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Announcement
32.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the aus- pices of Columbia University, Announcement
33.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the aus- pices of Columbia University, Announcement
34.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the aus- pices of Columbia University, Announcement
35.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Report of the Director; San Juan, PR; University of Porto Rico and Columbia University; 1936. (Archives and Special Collections, A.C. Long Health Science Library, Columbia Uni- versity).
36.Jarausch KH. Social education and social change: Some comparative perispective. In: Jarausch KH (ed.). The Transformation of Higher Learning
37.Ramírez de Arellano AB. Education for public health in Puerto Rico:
School of Tropical Medicine Educational Legacy
38.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Announcement
39.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Report of the Director
40.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Announcement
41.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Announcement
Rabionet
42.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Report of the Director
43.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Report of the Director
44.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Report of the
45.School of Tropical Medicine of the University of Porto Rico under the auspices of Columbia University, Report of the Director
PRHSJ Vol. 35 No. 3 • September, 2016 |
133 |
Published by the University of Puerto Rico Medical Sciences Campus
Founded in 1982